
Theme speaker. Emmanuel J. Barbeau
CerCo, CNRS – Université de Toulouse, UMR 5549, Toulouse, France
THEME TALK
Rethinking thalamic lesions: why intrathalamic white matter matters for cognition
The thalamus is a deep and anatomically complex structure comprising more than 30 nuclei in humans. Most studies have accordingly focused on individual nuclei, which are sometimes grouped into regions (e.g., the anterior nuclear group) or divided into subregions (e.g., the parvocellular and magnocellular parts of the mediodorsal nucleus). This has produced a strongly nucleus-centred view of the thalamus. Although this view is valid, it overlooks the white matter structures embedded within the thalamus, which also contribute to the functions the thalamus supports. When these structures are damaged, cognitive deficits may be exacerbated, or worse misattributed, and the functional role of thalamic nuclei may be misinterpreted. Many neuroimaging studies illustrate this problem. They consider only thalamic nuclei, even though the deficits they report, and attribute to specific nuclei, may equally result from concurrent damage to thalamic white matter.
The clinical literature shows the same difficulty. Thalamic lesions with similar topography can produce strikingly different cognitive outcomes, ranging from dense amnesia to near-normal performance. Classical accounts explain these differences by the specific nuclei involved. We argue that part of the unexplained variance reflects intrathalamic white matter structures that are visible on high-quality MRI: the mammillothalamic tract (MTT), the interthalamic adhesion (IA) and the internal medullary lamina (IML).
For each structure, we review its anatomy and its visibility on MRI, and we illustrate how it can be co-lesioned in thalamic pathologies. We then discuss why these structures remain difficult to study. Their small size relative to imaging resolution, partial volume effects, low anisotropy and the dense fiber crossings of thalamic tissue all limit their characterization. These constraints make the thalamus even harder to study with current MRI resolution. Nevertheless, we believe that taking these white matter structures into account provides a more complete account of the thalamus's role in cognition.










